Beau Travail Ready, Set, Cinema Denis examines Western imperialist Russell reassesses Desert This insight is as complicated That’s witty–it’s Three Kings’ Russell knows American movies Neither Beau Travail The Gulf War, unlike Vietnam, Such images let Russell Only someone who swallowed Next week I’ll report Julien Donkey-Boy Responding to the era’s What the gullible media It’s not avant-garde, But the media’s always
directed by Claire Denis
Kings should have opened the New York Film Festival
as a gateway to the extraordinary fall movie season. This satire about America’s
1991 Gulf War against Iraq’s Saddam Hussein that killed hundreds of thousands
of people and won the closed hearts and narrow minds of sleepy American patriots
is actually a wake-up call to how bracing and political pop culture can be.
Many people, having forgotten when American pop cinema used to be astute, may
have given up the idea that movies can delight, convey meaning and affect the
way you see yourself in the world. So they go to film festivals for distanced
sober seriousness. Yet Three Kings’ war comedy is so incisive–making
points with every bomb and shootout–that it startlingly connects to the
most erudite and fastidious European art films, like one of this year’s
New York Fest highlights, Claire Denis’ Beau Travail.
impulse through an iconic, formally precise update of Melville’s Billy
Budd. Poeticizing the internal politics of a single, jealous French Legionnaire
(Denis Lavant), her subject is first-world citizens’ personal indoctrination
to military hierarchy and ideology. Denis evokes Ousmane Sembene’s study
of how militarism and colonialism affected individual soldiers in Camp
de Thiaroye, and both these artists’ global/personal visions dovetail
with the conscientiousness that makes Three Kings so brilliant. As George
Clooney, Ice Cube and Mark Wahlberg (our troops) tear through the Middle East
sand dunes looking for gold hidden among the weapons stockpiles, director-writer
David O. Russell also kicks George Bush’s asshole politics across the desert.
Most of all, Three Kings tears through the barrier of political indifference–the
apathy of individuals who comprise both the pop audience and the Gulf War military.
Few critics have appreciated the superb achievement of this film, and it’s
too good to let slip away. Unlike the past decade’s culture of denial (which
Russell and Denis upbraid), Three Kings reminds us we do have personal
responses to art and politics.
Storm mania. Like Denis, he’s aware of how contemporary private citizens
deny their political status. This is not regular movie material. Denis goes
at it abstractly, but Russell unearths American political indifference by showing
its roots in the GIs’ illiteracy and back-home poverty and the rapacious
urge of news reporters exploiting the desert conflict as their own career opportunities.
The American urge is both libidinous and materialistic–Russell’s observation,
not cynical judgment. Capt. Archie Gates (Clooney), Sgt. Troy Barlow (Wahlberg)
and Staff Sgt. Elgin (Cube) find an opportunity to reward their tours of duty
by stealing Saddam’s gold bullion. It’s a typically selfish American,
post-Communist impulse, vividly underscored (proven) by the soundtrack motifs
"Can’t Do Nuttin’ For Ya Man" by Public Enemy and Snap’s
"The Power" ("I will attack/And you don’t want that!").
Russell shares the joy we all take from American pop (it’s played during
sex and dancing among the coed GIs), and he understands how pop incitements
to pleasure and fantasy contribute to a blase social attitude that the era’s
politicians could exploit for larger, alien, aggressive purposes.
as the psychological study of Beau Travail (the title’s an ironic
term for the best work available to the ungainfully employed). Russell, whose
previous film, Flirting With Disaster, pondered the young generation’s
ideological inheritance, now extends that film’s study to the moral choices
Gulf War enlistees faced. Essentially they’re pop consumers; that’s
their birthright and their connection to the very people they’ve been sent
to fight. The Iraqis are also neocapitalists, hoarding watches, tvs, cell phones
and deluxe, gas-guzzling automobiles. Russell treats global commerce as a great
sick joke. (His Three Kings title kids the traditional Christmas carol
cuz the gift American mercenaries bear is bombs and artillery and greed.) The
Yankee bandits discover unexpected solidarity with the (Third) world our culture
normally subordinates. They’re caught between surrendering Iraqi soldiers
and desperate civilians encouraged by U.S. policy to fight Saddam Hussein but
now, as powerless refugees, looking to the three kings for help. Amid the land
mines, buried treasure, aerial gas bombs and Louis Vuitton luggage, wartime
confusion expresses the modern geopolitical dilemma.
also why Three Kings is festival-worthy. This agit-pop dares to make
politically risky statements about American might and righteousness; it even
subverts postmodern cynicism to revitalize humanist impulses. That’s what
healthy pop art does. In Beau Travail Denis takes the artsiness of Malick’s
Thin Red Line and uses it for politically conscious purposes–another
meditation on existence, but influenced by Frantz Fanon and the Genet of Prisoner
of Love. Russell shows equal astuteness in the way he updates the GI platoon
movie, doing honor to Michael Curtiz’s swashbucklers and Sam Peckinpah’s
The Wild Bunch. That’s about as thrilling and moral as movies get.
opening begins, "The War Just Ended" (referring to Bush’s March
1991 ceasefire) but Russell means something more: the war over Pop Art doesn’t
really end. Films like Godard’s Le Petit Soldat and Les Carabiniers
and the NYFF itself once waged battle by keeping art and ideology alive. And
Beau Travail continues in its elegant way: repeated scenes of the white
Legionnaires scoping Arab girls in a disco capture the timeless complex of fascination
and exploitation. Denis digs deep into psycho-political confusion but not better
than Three Kings reifies America’s cultural domination. The dynamism
of great pop–a Hum-Vee cassette-player impudently changing from Bach to
the Beach Boys ("I Get Around") while GIs enter a desert city–complicates
pleasure with the problem of Western privilege.
used to combine intelligence and sport–that was the early promise of this
century’s great art form. But pop has been debased lately; comedy and action
became decadent and self-serving around the time of Desert Storm. A friend enthused
about Three Kings, "This is the kind of movie Tarantino would make
if he had politics." Right, but he’d also need the right politics,
not casual indifference to policy and issues but a principled concern with what
Americans hold dear as well as what they hold speciously. Inside Desert Storm’s
ideological maelstrom, Russell explores exactly those prerogatives. Along with
propaganda murals of Saddam in cap and gown, a Rodney King video plays in an
Iraqi bunker; a soldier races through underground tunnels carrying blue jeans
as booty; when Troy is interrogated by an Iraqi he’s asked, "What
is the problem with Michael Jackson?"–a serious question with which
Russell poses the fullest moral, racial inquiry, a great Godardian moment. Then
when Troy is questioned about U.S. policy, his all-American ignorance is rewarded
as per custom–a CD stuck in his mouth and oil poured down his throat.
nor Le Petit Soldat surpasses such agit-pop. Russell’s directing
skills now include visual allegory as well as character nuance. His widescreen
compositions have comic-strip brilliance, using space to show the disastrous
desert fires and distance to dramatize the phenomenon of violence–lively
sequences to instruct a new generation on the effects of violence by slowing
down bullet trajectory or, in an inspired f/x, going inside a wound to show
its impact on internal organs. It isn’t grisly, it’s a pop provocation
that redresses conventional movie gore with conscientious visual humor.
depended upon the modern audience’s desensitization to violence; that’s
what a tv reporter implies when proclaiming that Desert Storm "exorcised
the ghost of Vietnam with a clear moral imperative." Three Kings
refutes such media propaganda with a sharp sense of how 90s morality has become
unclear. (Troy imagines several brief flashes of domestic brutality that
give him an emotional bond with his grief-stricken torturer.) In an astounding
battle between rebels and Iraqi soldiers, Russell details an Iraqi mother being
shot in head. This not only balances excitement with horror, but evokes the
famous shocking photograph of a Vietnam execution, raising the stakes of movie
consciousness. Russell asks for a long-overdue moral response, wondering, Can
conscience be affected by art? By pop cruelty? Cinematographer Newton Thomas
Sigel desaturates the desert to heighten awareness. The mother’s blood
flows into the sand, black as oil.
triumph over the banality of war/action movies. Three Kings ranks with
such American triumphs as M*A*S*H and Walter Hill’s Trespass
that used conventional form to express modern anxiety. Instead of glamorizing
war (or Hollywood immorality) Russell turns the enjoyment of genre to political
effect. Denis works similarly with her Billy Budd archetypes, but Ice
Cube’s ethnic sensitivity and religious faith, Wahlberg’s working-class
simplicity (and in a smaller role, Spike Jonze’s trailer park pathos) are
more directly effective. Also recognizable is Clooney’s neo-Gable machismo:
self-centered yet weary of American habit, he sees past the greed to the humanism
the war requires of him. In a wonderful turnabout Capt. Gates leads his troops
to join the rebels. His speech is a wily joke on how sincerity has been degraded
into cant. ("We will rise up together, many races, many nations.")
He isn’t simply selling brotherhood, but an authentically American notion
of its accessories–Lexuses and Infinities.
CIA propaganda or felt Bush’s self-proclaimed war was just could find fault
with Russell’s lampoon. Any movie that keeps you surprised and thinking,
that clarifies current moral amazement, deserves a high five–and the appellation
"art." Not just the stuff of European intellectuals (Kusturica’s
unwatchable Black Cat, White Cat), movie art can include the energy that
Three Kings epitomizes but that Americans are prone to take for granted.
During a great week of New York Film Festival screenings, it’s Three
Kings that announces conscientious art is still possible in Hollywood; that
an indie director like Russell can rise from the fringes, integrity intact;
and that 1999’s fall movie season is gonna be magnificent. The best Festival
entries so far are Mike Leigh’s Topsy-Turvy, Spike Jonze’s
Being John Malkovich, the Dardenne Brothers’ Rosetta and
Pedro Almodovar’s All About My Mother. Together with David Lynch’s
The Straight Story and Steven Soderbergh’s The Limey, it’s
enough to make you believe in a pop renaissance.
on Festival trailblazers Boys Don’t Cry and Pola X.
directed by Harmony Korine
hypertechnology, young folks want to believe in realism again–even if it’s
faked and gilded with real-life mutations, perversions, aberrations and deformities.
That’s why Harmony Korine’s mix of actors and freaks gets taken seriously.
Now he claims adherence to the already specious Dogma 95 movement of Danish
filmmakers. But Korine’s second film, Julien Donkey-Boy, simply uses that
gimmick to sell this exploitation of what he admits dramatizes his schizophrenic
(as obtuse as art-critic Giuliani) don’t understand is that Korine isn’t
serious. Like his other relative, Huntz Hall of the Bowery Boys, he’s a
comedian. Korine’s slapdash surveys of American seaminess is nothing more
than cruel comedy–he dares you not to laugh at the albino rapper, armless
card dealer and drummer, obese dancer, German-fascist father, the incestuous
pregnant teen, the blind children bowling and ice-skating, and the exotic, superstitious
blacks in church.
but, veritably, a cable access Gong Show. Using expensive video technology
for editing, colorizing and up to 30 cameras including one- and two-chip digital
cams, Korine contradicts Dogma 95 ascetic precepts, a fatuous pretense anyway.
Casting Werner Herzog as the father provides no validation. Herzog himself may
like showcasing freaks, but he’s also a genius–with a great visual
sense–and as an actor he improvises better absurdities than Korine conceives.
Following Julien (Ewen Bremner) to the church, Korine shows him looking lost
and crying, but no wonder: Korine jump-cuts the sermon to be incomprehensible.
All it shows is Korine’s skepticism and contempt for anyone’s normality
or attempt at coping. His deliberate obsession with obfuscation and obliteration
culminates in a blind girl saying, "I thought I could really see,"
until being told she couldn’t. More cruelly, the preggers teen (Chloe Sevigny)
asks, "How do you think the future looks for the baby?" and the blind
girl answers, "Bright." That’s more than one desires for Korine’s
ready for a naked emperor; so are naive cinephiles. And Korine’s punkish
anger and nescience flatter their fearful stupidity. Reflecting a nihilist
generation’s self-regard and doom, Julien kills a child, rapes his sister
and becomes part of a cycle: Indifferent God/Bad Father/Retarded Julien. Even
when Julien takes the stillborn fetus from the delivery room and huddles up
in bedclothes like a mutant newborn, Korine still dares you to laugh. And you
should. He’s made history’s most exalted Dead Baby Joke.
Ready, Set, Cinema
Denis examines Western imperialist
Russell reassesses Desert
This insight is as complicated
Russell knows American movies
Neither Beau Travail
The Gulf War, unlike Vietnam,
Such images let Russell
Only someone who swallowed
Next week I’ll report
Responding to the era’s
What the gullible media
It’s not avant-garde,
But the media’s always