The Piano Surely the Shafer’s This gives More scene-conscious It’s this "You working?" "Excuse "You know, "Uh, look. "Well, "What "You’ll At the heart Similarly, It’s By the end,
Teacher and Y Tu Mama Tambien are the kinds of hit movies that make
you despair of unexamined popular attitudes. Audiences go to them out of simple
prurient curiosity, but these films are encrusted with pretense rather than
delight. The first exploits bourgeois neurosis through the story of a pent-up
European classical musician, and the second exploits youthful recklessness by
following two Mexican students’ Third World road trip; both movies corrupt
pleasure. Midway through each, you may wonder why you’re watching.
The commentary on either European stultification or Latin machismo is predictable
to the point of feeling hackneyed. It’s far more interesting to pull oneself
through Circuit, an expose of the shadily financed, not-quite-underground
gay party scene, because its familiar sexual attitudes are indeed examined–at
appeal of The Piano Teacher and Y Tu Mama Tambien starts with
the empowered, socially sanctioned view of heterosexuality that most moviegoers
are accustomed to watching and affirming–even though Michael Haneke, who
directed The Piano Teacher, and Alfonso Cuaron, who directed Y Tu
Mama Tambien, emphasize heterosexual kink. Circuit benefits from
taking particular kinks–dependency on drugs, looks, money and the dance
club’s removed yet intensified atmosphere of license–as the stuff
of urban gay drama and making it perplexing. Director-writer Dirk Shafer differs
from Haneke and Cuaron in his effort to sum up and legitimize subcultural experience.
Admittedly less accomplished than Haneke or Cuaron, Shafer’s effort
is more meaningfully ambitious. He takes a wider social perspective that, despite
some half-mawkish episodes, is honestly, personally revelatory.
first film was the 1995 documentary Man of the Year, about his own hoax
as a gay male Playgirl model–a rare look at cultural imposture.
Circuit’s three lead characters–Johnny Webster (Jonathan Wade
Drahos), a white Midwestern ex-cop who moves to L.A.; Hector (Andre Khabbazi),
a Latino hustler; and Bobby (Paul Lekakis), a stripper and model–are caught
up in their own self-deceptions, a result of competing in an environment–West
Hollywood–that requires reinventing oneself as a libertine ideal. Shafer
and co-writer Gregory Hinton are clearly fascinated with the move past coming-out–the
leap beyond conventional romantic relationships that is inherent to most gay
men’s self-realization. The characters, well into adulthood, hazardously
come of age in a culture that insists on youthful audacity. Seasonal circuit
parties–the Red Party, the Black Party, the White Party–are where
they meat and greet.
Circuit a genuine, rich subject, whereas The Piano Teacher is,
essentially, a highbrow freak show with the glum Isabelle Huppert getting off
on a humorless secret life as a masochistic dominatrix. And Y Tu Mama Tambien
is just a puppyish sex romp in which two 17-year-olds (Gael Garcia Bernal, Diego
Luna) and a slightly older woman (Maribel Verdu) don’t get past
their adolescent selfishness. (Set in Mexico, it’s a long day’s journey
toward American Pie.) If it weren’t for the hegemony of big-screen
hetero sex, audiences might reject those films’ "seriousness"
as sham. Neither picture offers the currency of the moment to be found in Circuit.
Shafer seems entranced by the music (a soundtrack set on perpetual ecstasy)
and the bodies–prerequisites for any filmmaker exploring sex in contemporary
than profound, Circuit’s more than two-hour epic format is quite
an advance after a satirical documentary. Shafer may not be telling all he knows
about the gay pillage-and-plunder demimonde (there’s a hustling scene shot
from a voyeur’s point of view, not an artist’s) but he shows an amusing,
highbrow/lowbrow aspiration: to be Stendhal writing a gay Valley of the Dolls
on film. As it opens with Johnny passed out in a toilet stall, you wonder: where
can the story go? But that’s the point; Shafer’s urge to reveal just
makes him inexact about telling it. Johnny’s Illinois backstory ("Have
you ever considered relocating to an environment more compatible with your lifestyle?"
his captain asks) suggests a movie mostly located in his mind. He didn’t
need to go to L.A. to cruise T-rooms, but L.A. is where a little-recognized
genre of gay neo-humanism has been developing. Movies like Punks,
The Broken Hearts Club and the moving It’s My Party obviously
inspired Shafer by presenting WeHo realness and some memorable characters (like
Paul Winfield’s aging sugar daddy in Mike’s Murder) while offering
mix of pop gay attitudes–not extraordinarily observed like the British
Queer as Folk, yet not glib like Will & Grace–that justifies
Circuit’s unresolved tumult of character types and social effrontery.
Shafer’s imagination cranks once Johnny meets Hector.
If this is your territory, not to worry."
even if you were working, I wouldn’t worry. You’re one type, I’m
type are you?"
of Circuit is this love story that dare not speak its vulnerability.
The roundelay between Johnny, Hector and Bobby–and Johnny’s documentarian
cousin Tad (Daniel Kucan), Tad’s ex-lover Gill (Brian Lane Green), his
current lover Julian (Darryl Stephens) and Johnny’s former girlfriend Nina
(Kiersten Warren, who has a fine moment deliberately confusing "circuit"
with "circus")–reflects something of the transience and delusions
of urban sex life. This soap-opera naivete gives Circuit resonance, unlike
the more sophisticated hits undercut by their blatant attempts at shock. Critics
have likened Y Tu Mama to Bertrand Blier’s thoroughly weird Going
Places, but Y Tu Mama isn’t weird enough. Its big scene (a drunken,
reticent menage a trois) shows none of Blier’s rebelliousness–which
still shocks one’s movie reflexes when Gerard Depardieu jumps Patrick Dewaere.
Blier’s impudence swayed more than machismo. Cuaron (who previously directed
Gwyneth Paltrow in his intolerably daft update of Great Expectations)
is primarily a sap with an Interview sensibility. He falls back on a
sentimental sex/politics voiceover that is just a bad imitation of earlier French
New Wave tropes Blier was bold enough to discard. Cuaron reduces Mexico to a
NAFTA travelogue. Like Amores Perros, his film shows Mexico’s new
generation of filmmakers stealing second-rate status from the Australians; he
arrives late at Western hipness.
dread echoes of Jane Campion makes The Piano Teacher a trial to sit through–even
though its obvious polemic on female sexual prerogative contradicts Campion’s
late feminist view. The German Haneke confronts middle-class hypocrisy (bolstered
by Schubert recitals) as if Fassbinder never happened. He backs into a perverse
view of feminism, aided by Huppert taking out her sexual frustration on gullible
students and her snooping mother (Annie Girardot), and finally achieving humiliation
from a randy male pupil (Benoit Magimel, the only fresh performance). In American
movies Jennifer Jason Leigh has turned such quiet neurosis into humane lyricism;
it’s a bad cultural twist that Huppert gets overpraised for dimming her
pathetic character’s soul.
Shafer’s attempt at soul–turning pretty boys into persons with emotional
baggage–that validates Circuit. Drahos’ tall, classically sculptured
Y-torso puts Johnny in that Zak Spears/Fred MacMurray/Peter Jennings mold, a
look of perfected Caucasian types that is the bane of the gay mainstream. When
stoned or desperate, Drahos assumes a boyish Pierce Brosnan pique. From the
moment he meets Hector (a Latino Dack Rambo type) their tension is largely social.
Hector has gotten by in a world of sexualized racial elites only by measuring
himself against their reflection. Telling Johnny, "You’ve got everything.
You’re educated, you’re smart," he actually admits his envy of
white, middle-class advantages, while Johnny simply calls him "papi."
Shafer doesn’t go much deeper, but his diffidence–exemplified by Johnny’s
putting on attitude sunglasses to druggily explain himself (a gesture recalling
Jean-Pierre Leaud in The Mother and the Whore)–says a lot. He’s
daunted by the circuit scene’s hidden tragedies.
Circuit breaks down into preachiness; one party twink says, "Drugs
promote safe sex," another says, "We’re killing ourselves."
(There’s even a wicked party promoter played by William Katt who beats
his wife, played by still charming Nancy Allen.) But there’s one moment
of remarkable honesty when Johnny asks a veteran partier, "How’d you
get through being gay–having all this incredible freedom?" The answer,
"Things were different. Then, you thought you were getting away with something,"
cuts to the heart of sex-movie popularity–effectively exposing Haneke’s
and Cuaron’s arrogance. This reality check may prove too thoughtful for
Circuit to get away with trendy success, but who knows? It’s opening
in time for beach fiction.
At the heart
By the end,